THE return of Jews to
Palestine has been very
marked during the last
ten years. The
possibility that thousands
may return is great. Up
to 1832 European Jews
were repeatedly banished
from the land. In 1874
an accurate statistician
gave the number of Jews
living in Palestine as
10,000. The same person,
twenty years later, in
1894, estimates that
49,960 lived then in the
leading towns of
Palestine; an increase
in twenty years of about
40,000. In the last ten
years the Jewish
population in Palestine
has almost
doubled.
Jerusalem has never been
such a "Jewish" city
since the year 70 as it
is to-day, and the city
has, with its railroad
station, electric
lights, etc., quite a
modern appearance. The
Jews living in the land
are from almost every
country of the world.
This in itself is a
significant fact.
Some years ago we
printed in "Our Hope" a
series of articles on
the Jews in Palestine
and their condition. The
information comes from a
reliable source1 and we
give part
of it now:
I. The Jews of Palestine
are very various as to
origin; they are indeed
from all parts of the
world. A rough division
may be made into the
Arabic-speaking and the
Yiddish-speaking Jews.
Of the first mentioned,
the great majority
are the Sephardim Jews,
who have resided in the
Turkish Empire for many
generations.
It is well known that at
the time of the Crusades
there were very few Jews
in Palestine-probably at
most not more than about
a thousand. The Jews in
Jerusalem itself were
nearly all killed in
1099. by the Crusaders.
After the fall of the
Kingdom of Jerusalem
they began to return,
and early in the
thirteenth century we
hear of 300 Jewish
rabbis from France and
England coming to the
Holy Land. The larger
number, however, of the
present Sephardim are
descendants of those
Jews who were driven out
of Spain in 1492 by the
edicts of Ferdinand and
Isabella. The majority
of these have found
their way to Palestine
from other parts of the
Turkish Empire, and
notably from
Constantinople. Through
all their years of
wandering since they
left Spain they have
maintained their
Spanish-a Spanish which,
of course (as in every
language spoken by
Jews), is amplified by
the addition of
Hebraisms, but which
keeps the leading
characteristics of the
Spanish of 466 years
ago. All the Sephardim
know Arabic, and those
living in the North-in
ancient Galilee and
Syria-speak Arabic
habitually, and have in
the majority of cases
completely dropped
Spanish. It is very
curious whereas the
communities at
Jerusalem, Hebron, and Jaffa, etc., speak
Spanish constantly, the
same communities in
Safed, Tiberias, and
Damascus scarcely use
any Spanish at all.
During a residence of
some months in Galilee I
only met one or two
persons who knew
Spanish, and they were
from Jerusalem.
It will be convenient to
class under this heading
many smaller groups of
Eastern Jews. Of these.
I would mention
especially the Mugrabin
or Marocco, the Yemenite
and the Georgian or
Circassian Jews. There
are also many small
communities of Jews from
Aleppo, Bagdad. Persia
and Bokhara, who keep
themselves in many
respects apart
from others.
The Mugrabin or Marocco
Jews are particularly
poor, and are probably
the most degraded of all
the Jewish communities.
They speak the Arabic
dialect of North Africa,
from whence they come,
and in some leading
characteristics resemble
the Mugrabin Arabs who
have come to Palestine
at various times. They
are very closely
identified with the
Sephardim in religious
ritual.
The Yemen Jew is from
South Arabia, and is
distinguished by his
swarthy skin, his
coal-black hair, his
cork-screw forelock, and
his complete familiarity
with what is recognized
in Jerusalem as the good
dialect of Arabic. They
are a poor community,
mostly in rags, though
they are hard-working.
As they have been in
Jerusalem only about a
dozen years, and arrived
penniless, they have not
yet had time to
establish a good
position for themselves
Except for the
cork-screw forelock,
their appearance would
never lead an
inexperienced observer
to suspect that he was
looking upon a Jew.
Many of them are very
dark indeed-much darker
than the Fellahin of the mountains.
A very different
community from the two
mentioned is that of the
Gourgee or Circassian
Jews. These come from
Kurdistan and still
further north. In many
of their physiognomical
peculiarities, as well
as in their dress, they
resemble the Circassians, who
were once their
neighbors. They are a
fine, tall race, with
long fair faces,
generally dark hair and
prominent features. They
have none of the
cringing servility of an
average Ashkenaz Jew. As
a community they are
comparatively rich, and
have established
them-selves both inside
and outside the walls of
Jerusalem, and in
smaller numbers in
Jaffa. Russian and
Georgian arc their
native languages, and
many take advantage of
their knowledge of the
former to supply the
necessity of the Russian
pilgrims.
The remaining Eastern
Jews are from various
parts of the Eastern
Turkish Empire, from
Persia, from Central
Asia and India. Of
these, the richest and
most prosperous are the
Jews from Bokhara, who
form an increasing
com-munity, and are now
building some handsome
houses a little way out
of the city of
Jerusalem. The Bokhara
Jews are physically well
developed, and both the
Jews and Jewesses dress
in cloths of the most
fantastic colors, in
which bright yellows and
reds play a prominent
part. Some of their
garments remind one of
the fantastic dresses
forced upon the heretics
condemned to be burnt by
the Spanish Inquisition.
The second great
community of Jews in
Palestine, and the one
which is yearly becoming
of greater importance,
is the Ashkenaz
community. This is
composed of Jews from
Russia, Poland, Germany
and Austria, chiefly.
The characteristic Jew
of Whitechapel is an
Ashkenaz Jew. Although
the community is
primarily from the
countries mentioned
above, they come from
most European countries,
and by
secondary emigration,
from North America the
Cape of Good Hope, and
Australia. This class of
Jews has only been
allowed to settle in Palestine since 1832,
before which date they
were repeatedly
expelled. The type is so
well known to English
people that it seems
hardly worth while to
enlarge upon it. They
usually have fair hair
and light eyes. but otherwise
the cast of face appears
to be mud; modified,
according to whether
they come from Russia.
Germany or further west.
Hooked noses, supposed
vulgarly to be a
characteristic of Jews,
are not by any means
common. The language of
the Ashkenaz Jew is. as
is well known. Yiddish-a
language which, while in
its foundation German
differs greatly from it
in pronunciation and
grammatical
construction. It is too
corrupted by the
individual speaking it who introduces
Russian. Polish, German
or English into it according
to taste. It goes
without saying that
Yiddish is not Yiddish
without a good sprinkling
of Hebrew words. The
Ashkenaz community are
divided into two great
groups, the Perushim and
the Chassidim, from
differences in
religious ritual which
do not concern us here.
It should be mentioned
that there is a sprinkling
of Jews from France,
who, in proportion to
their small numbers have
a great influence among
the other Jews in the
country, both intellectually and religiously. It is of great
interest to every
scientific observer to
notice how completely
the Jews, while
remaining a separate
people, have in
physiognomy, in dress and
to a great extent in
habit, become like the
people among whom they
have so long dwelt. The
Sephardim Jew the
Yemenite, and the Mugrabin, are all very
like the Arabs of
their respective places
of long residence; the
Georgian Jew is very
much like the Circassian.
Among the Ashkenaz Jews
one finds many a Russian
Jewess in outward appearance the image of
the Russian pilgrim who
haunts Jerusalem at
Easter time, while many
a comely Jewess from
hap-pier surroundings in
Germany has an
unmistakable German
physiognomy.2
The vast majority of the
Jews are naturally
Turkish subjects, and
can claim no other
protection. Many come
into the country as
subjects of other
nations, but their
children become subjects
of the Ottoman Empire.
Some years ago, many
Jews made a great effort
to come under the
protection of Great
Britain, but after
considerable numbers
were enrolled as
British subjects, further additions were
prevented by order of
the British Government.
Most, if not all. the
Bokhara and some of the
Gourgee Jews are under
Russian protection.
Every community, even
the small ones, is, in
religious matters,
governed by its own
Chief Rabbi; but all the
Jews of Palestine are
officially under the
Chief Rabbi of Jerusalem, who holds a
firman from the Sultan,
has his own cavass or
Turkish guard, and is,
in Jerusalem, only
second in authority to
the Pashaw. Hitherto
this official has always
been drawn from the
Sephardim community, but
the Ashkenazim. on
account of their
increasing numbers, are
hoping to have one of their own
number elected to the
port before long.
II. From this somewhat
scanty account of the
Jewish communities in
Palestine let us now
turn to their condition and
prospects. It will be
convenient in
considering this divide
off the Jews of
Palestine into four
rough classes.
(1) Those Jews who spend
their whole time in
purely religious
occupations--e. g.
the
study of the sacred
books-and those whose
great object in coming
to the country is to
die on holy soil.
(2) Jews who have,
perhaps, come to the
country from religious
motives, but who have
still to earn their
living to assist out their scanty "Haluka,"
the allowance they receive from funds
contributed by Jews of
other countries for
their support.
(3) Those who have
been brought up in the
country, and
have had to earn their
own living unassisted.
(4) Jews who have by
various philanthropic
agencies
been settled in
agricultural communities
on the land.
It should
also perhaps be
mentioned that there are
besides
these a considerable
number of paupers
subsisting on local charity. Some of these
have got admission into
the country in a state of
penury, and have through
various reasons been
unable to rise above
their poverty. It is
well known that they
generally do rise if
their surroundings make
it possible, others are
widows with children,
whose husbands came into
the country in perhaps
enfeebled health, for religious purposes, or
who perchance, always lived "from hand to
mouth." Yet others are
remnants of a time when
it was thought that all
the rising generation
should learn only to
read the Talmud and
despise a trade. These
very poor Jews occur of
course in the large
towns, but more
especially in the two
largest Jewish
communities, Jerusalem
and Safed. Some are
beggars by profession.
It must not be thought,
as many would think who
read the erroneous
accounts published
regarding Jerusalem,
that a very large
proportion belong to
this class. It is a
class much to be pitied,
but not, I believe, so
needy nor so large a
class as in most
European cities.
(I) With regard to the
Chachams (i. e.,
"sages," included in
class I), who in all
communities are
supported for their
religious duties, it is
unnecessary to say much.
They are, if
sufficiently learned,
fairly well provided for
by the Haluka, which is
collected for this
purpose from all parts
of the world. In the
Sephardim community of
Jerusalem, the Chachams
who devote their whole
time to the study of the
law, number upwards of
300 families, and from
this number certain
"messengers of the
congregations" are
deputed to travel all
over the world to
collect funds for the
support of the whole
body of religious men.
They often travel far: I
know one such messenger
personally, who has
visited on this errand
almost every European
country, as well as
India, North Africa, and
America. These
messengers are well
paid, and the posts are
naturally coveted.
Among the Sephardim
almost all the Haluka
goes to the chief men:
there are a few minor
appointments which help
a few, but the great
bulk of these Jews have
no special fund, though
there are many
charitable institutions
for providing houses
and other assistance.
In the Ashkenaz
communities, on the
other hand, almost all
the individuals receive
some pecuniary
assistance, but it
varies very much
according to the place
from which it
comes.
The whole Ashkenaz
community is divided
into two great
groups—the Perushim and
the Chassidim—but each
of these divisions is
with respect to the
Haluka subdivided: Thus,
the Perushim Ashkenazim
from Warsaw have a fund
to divide among
themselves sent from
Warsaw; those from Minsk
have another fund
derived from that
district, and so on.
There are nine main
subdivisions under the
Jerusalem Perushim, and
five under the Jerusalem
Chassidim Jews. Not only
does the Haluka vary
very much according as
to whence it comes, but
as the communities in
Europe, especially in
Russia, have got poorer,
the Haluka has got less
and less, and many of
the Jews could not
possibly live on it
alone.
Many of the Chachams
among the Ashkenazim,
however, have come to
Palestine in extreme old
age or in failing middle
age to pass their
declining years in
studying the Law and the
other sacred books on
sacred soil, and to lay
their bones within Holy
Land. This is the case
with great numbers in
the "colonies" around
Jerusalem, and perhaps
more so still in Safed,
where most of the
Ashkenazim belong to
that category.
A certain
proportion of the
members of the smaller
communities belong to this
class. Not a few of this
class have come with a
good income, either sent
to them from their old
homes or derived from
savings brought with
them.
(2) By easy steps we
pass to the second
class, where we find men
who have come from
purely religious
motives, but, finding it
impossible to manage on
their Haluka, or,
perhaps, marrying in
middle life and
burdening themselves
thus with extra cares
and expenses, are
obliged to do something
to earn a livelihood.
Many of this latter
class become tailors,
small shopkeepers, etc.,
while among the
Sephardim Chachams some
may find extra
remuneration as teachers
and readers of the
Mishna, offers of
prayers with the sick,
etc. Some have a kind of
hereditary right to some
assistance from some of
the colleges (so-called)
for reading the Talmud,
though they do not
themselves necessarily
study
much.
(3) We next come to the
very interesting class
of Jews who are earning
their livelihood in the
country in various ways,
and with these I wish to
deal somewhat more at
length. It will be
noticed that those
previously mentioned are
more or less living on
the earnings of others
and spending money sent
to them from other
lands. Like so large a
proportion of residents
in the country, they
live on the religious
enthusiasm of their
co-religionists in their
old
homes.
The Jews engaged in
business in Palestine
are very numerous, and
they belong to all
classes of the
community; they are
found in all parts of
the country. Thus. if
you visit the towns
along the coast from
Gaza to Beyrout you
will find in every place
not only that there are
Jews in business, but
that a large proportion
of the business is in
their hands. There is no
town of importance in
the country without its
representative of the
nation, and in many
villages you will find
one or more Jews engaged
in keeping a "general
store," or in
"cobbling." or in
money-lending. When
traveling in the country
in 1893, I arrived with
a party at an
out-of-the-way village
called El Burj, on the
borders of the hill country
of Judea. about four
hours' ride from Lydda.
Scarcely were the tents been
set when out
came the inevitable Jew;
who this time was
engaged in cheese-making
for the benefit of the
Fellahin. When
journeying
in 1894 in Upper
Galilee, on the way to
Tyre and Sidon. I
stopped for the night at
the little village of
Rumash and there, sure
enough, was the Jew and
his little shop. In the
miserable, squalid
village of Jericho, in
the mountain fastness of
Kerak in Moab, and
amongst the Bedouin of
the Hauran (engaged in
corn-buying generally),
you will
come across Jews.
In Jerusalem, Jews have
most of the
money-changing and
money-lending in their
hands, and, except for
some German shops, they
do most of the general
business. The cleverest
of handicrafts are the
Ashkenazim, who have
most of the
furniture-making, olive wood work, plumber's
work, watch and
clockmaking,
book-binding. printing,
etc., while the
Sephardim are most
successful as drapers,
fancy trimming sellers,
etc. All classes, i.
e, Mugrabin and Yemens, as
well as those mentioned
above, flourish as
tailors, cobblers, rough
tinmen, etc.
Many act as
carriage-drivers in
places where carriages
are used, such as
Jerusalem, Jaffa, etc.,
and the poorer ones
carry loads on their
lacks, or go up and down
the country's "mokarris"
or
muleteers. Their
cleverness and industry
are indisputable. You
may watch many a Jew in
a miserable little place
where he has scarcely
room to move a leg, or
under a tiny awning, sit
tapping away at mending
shoes or soldering
together the many
wonderful tin articles
which he makes out of
old petroleum tins. The
competition is very
great and (as in the
east of London) the Jew
will work with a minimum
margin of profit. A list
of all the various
trades followed by Jews
in Palestine would fill
a whole page; but to
show that it is not only
the rougher trades which
are followed, I must
mention that I know of
Jews who are surgical
instrument makers,
chemists, electrical
machinists, broom
makers, etc.
It goes without saying
that the Jews derive a
very great share of
their custom in such
places as Jerusalem and
Jaffa from the various
religious societies
which exist there. They
work also for the
natives of the country;
indeed, there is much
work in the country,
introduced by the spread
of European ideas, which
only Jews can at present
do. There is however,
comparatively little
work for so many Jews to
do, and often the
competition is so severe
that the workers can
scarcely get enough to
live upon. There are
very few more openings
for Jews in the country,
and I do not hesitate to
say that, unless the
general prosperity of
the country increases in
some extraordinary and
unlooked for way. there
cannot be much more
opening for the Jews in
these directions. The Fellahin, on
the other hand, cannot
support more Jews,
useful as they might be
to them in many ways,
for the simple reason
that they are so ground
down by the Turkish
Government that they
have scarcely enough
money for the bare
necessities, let alone
luxuries, of life. No
doubt a certain number
may find openings for
work in the larger
villages, where the
simplest Jew is a genius
at hand-work compared
with the average Fellah;
but this at the outside
must be confined to a
hundred or two, and life
in the villages cannot
be very comfortable at
the best. Most of those
who now get money in the
villages have to
itinerate widely if they
are to get a sufficient
profit out of their expedition.
Very few Jews can get
rich in Palestine. It is
no uncommon thing for a
poor and apparently
pauper Jew to die in the
midst of one of the
communities, and for a
bag of money—one or two
hundred napoleons
perhaps—to be found
stowed away in some
secret place. But such
riches have seldom or
never been earned in the
country. It is the
remains of money brought
into the country from
abroad. Many a poor Jew,
having made his "pile,"
packs up his goods with
it and goes off to the
Holy Land to end his
days in peace.
|